March 16, 2012

Favorite Reviewer Quotes

  • "I find this paper very difficult to read. Also, how the algorithm is used is not clear to me." (I have better things to do.)
  • "Hard to quantify this comment, but section Y just feels boring and does not add much insight." (I need some sugar.)
  • "There is not much that is particularly novel or original in this paper, but it does appear to be a solid piece of engineering." (You worked hard, kudos for that.)
And with that*, a major portion of my dissertation work goes into print! (In a good place, I might add ;)

*Luckily for me, there were 5 reviewers total, and the ones that actually bothered to read the paper liked it!

4 comments:

CarlosPC said...

Maybe, MAYBE you will let us see your dissertation or at least some parts of it. Right?

CarlosPC said...

Maybe, MAYBE you will let us see your dissertation or at least some parts of it. Right?

EcoGeoFemme said...

Congratulations! That's great!

Cath@VWXYNot? said...

congratulations!